Q:was it ever told whether or not Sara Harvey was actually dead or not? Similarly to the Maya or Meredith storyline I can't honestly believe this information was given simply to distract us especially since there had never been any mention of Bethany until the season 4 finale. If it was never discovered whether or not she is dead then she may be involved somehow, maybe she's black veil?
I totally get what you mean and I still want believe her storyline is very important and I haven’t ruled her out of the equation as of yet. One reason is because while Bethany is mentioned as the body that was buried in place of Alison, we were never shown a photo of her meaning she could be anyone as of right now. A photo of Sara was shown in 4.14 meaning, we do have some indication of what she looked like.
I’m still under the impression that there are two dead girls and ‘A’ switched the bodies in Season 3 episode 1. I think the girl that was originally killed the night of Ali’s disappearance was Sara Harvey and whoever the Redcoat that was with Mona the night that Alison’s grave was dug up switched the bodies.
I’m thinking the body that ‘A’ was shown with in 3.03 is Sara’s body and due to ‘A’ removing body parts from the body and sending it to the girls.
'A' still have possession of this body and the body that was identified as Bethany's was in fact her's but the body pieces from above belongs to Sara. Also, this can be justified in 4.23 episode when the fingers from another body was within Spencer's dress accessory. Therefore, there's another body out there and it's very possible that it is Sara's.
The people that were murdered are the ones that were in Ali’s room that night, were conspiring against her, or buried her alive:
- Garret and Ian were in her room
- Jessica Diaurentis buried her alive
- Wilden was there due to Melissa’s call
- Mona convinced her to go away (according to Ali)
Therefore, it leaves Melissa, Jenna, Jason, and the liars. Someone tried to kill Jenna twice already, as well as Jason in the elevator, and Melissa haven’t been touched yet because she’s always moving from city to city. The liars have been attacked for 5 seasons,
Mona was attacked in her car, and Ezra was shot by A.
Mona was the one that shut down Emily’s car in 4.15:
#PLL Viewing her laptop and the laptop in the ending ‘A’ scene, it’s the exact same. Also, it makes sense now considering her excellent hacking skills.
Mona’s Mom mentioned Lesley. Could Lesley be Mona’s sister? Lesley + Mona = Leona (Mona’s mother)
Mona Went Out With A Fight - Possibility of How She Died
I love the fact that Janel Parrish mentioned to Zap2It that Mona went out with a fight. It’s comforting to know that she put up a fight with her murderer, so I tried to reenact the events that could have possibly resulted in her death.
1. The murderer picked the lock with SouthOrd jackknife lock pick.
These are very small but sharp picks that come in different styles.
Judging by the intruder, this was the only weapon visible to the audience when she walked into the home therefore, I assume this was used by suspect.
2. There was only one suspect/intruder in the home.
I am a strong believer that the person who walked through the front door was the only person in the house. I just don’t think Mona could have put up that big of a fight if there were two people in the home, it would’ve been like she had no chance at defending herself against two. So I’m saying there was only one person and that was the above blonde.
3. Mona was surprised to see Ali (she’s the murderer).
Mona had just mentioned Ali’s name in the mirror and this could have explained the expression on her face when she saw her open her room door. She wasn’t expecting to see Ali in her house. I would have been shocked too.
As I’ve mentioned in this post, I believe Alison murdered Mona and after comparing the hair strands and style I’m positive it was her. The neck, the highlights, the chopped ends, it wasn’t a wig at all it was 100% Alison. I’m not sure why her hair seems a lighter color when she walked through Mona’s door but the styling of the curls was definitely Ali.
4. Mona’s body had a cut on her left cheek.
The cut on Mona’s left cheek reminded me of 5.05 ‘Miss Me x100’ when Ali slapped Mona causing a cut on the same cheek. I think this was the producers/writers way of saying “coincidence?” Also, I think Ali could have used the the lockpick to make this cut on Mona’s cheek during the struggle. If you are quick enough and I think those little picks are sharp enough to make a deep cut.
5.There’s a cut on Mona’s forehead.
Mona’s body had a cut or bruise on her forehead indicating she was hit with an object or pushed into something. Judging by the broken mirror in the living room, I’d say she was pushed into that corner and possibly hit her head on something there.
As she was trying to get up, she grabbed the banister post which resulted in the amount of blood on the banister.
Cause of death, I think she was smothered with the pillow lying on the floor.
I’ve ruled Alison DiLaurentis as Mona’s Killer:
I was sure it someone else last night, but after re-watching the scene several times the body type, the walk was so similar to Alison.
Mona’s Killer could possibly be the same person that stood behind Ali in the Halloween store. He/She was dressed in the creepy doll costume and was also the person leaving out of the creepy house that Ali lured the liars to in her attempt to scare the girls.
Back in Season 2 of #PLL Mona tells Spencer - We’re in this Together Now
In last night’s episode ‘We’re all in this together” flashes on the TV screens. In next week’s episode Mona will team up with the liars, coincidence?
Will Mona Vanderwaal Really Die, or Does She Pull an Ali to Cover Tracks? #PLL
Things aren’t looking good for fan favorite, Mona Vanderwaal, after last night’s promo for the summer final of Pretty Little Liars, all clues seem to point to the villain turned liar, turned forgivable character. But why would the show risk getting rid of such an interesting character who brings so much to the storyline, whom flashback of the night that Alison DiLaurentis actually disappeared never been shown, only through the eyes of Alison herself who has proven to be untrustworthy? We are thinking this could be an interesting time to introduce a secret of the Vanderwaal’s plus the adding of Mona’s mother, played by actress Sydney Penny.
Mona’s character holds many secrets and her Radley involvement plays a prominent role to some of the clues surrounding the sanitarium. Why kill her off now? Her vengeance with Ali seems more believable than Jenna’s, whom we’ve seen working with Mona in the 100th episode. Janel Parrish (Mona Vanderwaal) character seems to be a leader amongst Jenna and Sydney and she’d mentioned to Ezra in the Season 4 Winter premiere that she was entitled to her revenge.
If there was any truth to Alison’s story in the Season 4 winter finale and Mona helped Ali fake her own death then it is very possible that Mona could be pulling a death hoax of her own. Through binge watching the series, Mona has been very careful covering her tracks through the liars mistakes, as her alias ‘A.’ After watching last night’s episode Tanner told Mr. Montgomery that “when things start to get more complicated you can be sure that someone is doing that on purpose. Someone smart.”
Mona has never failed when it comes to the brainiest on the show. She and Spencer Hastings are both intelligent individuals, but Mona has the ability to be very convincing and has also proven that she is a terrific liar.
Everything surrounding the death of Bethany Young is pointing to the liars. I recall the ‘Liars Guide to Rosewood’ that aired before the Season 4 summer premiere and Mona was the narrator. She mentions “A had a way of effecting every aspect of their lives, including their investigation into Ali’s murder.” Mona was ‘A’ during this particular time and it seems that she was the one sending the videos to the girls. If you notice, every piece of evidence that the liars have had in their possession has somehow been lost, stolen, or destroyed. Even the body of Bethany Young was stolen from Ali’s grave by Mona, Redcoat, and whomever took the pictures of the liars at the scene.
I’ve also noticed how Mona miraculously tossed the idea up “I should have died on that stupid cliff.” Then she goes on to warn Aria about Alison, this was a very smart move and sets up the storyline for Fatal Finale. Aria and the other liars will team up with Mona as they turn against former friend Alison. Could Mona only be using the liars to make her escape route? Blaming Alison for everything, therefore leaving her untrustworthy with the liars, and pinning everything on the girls, the death of Bethany Young and her murder? It would definitely make a very interesting plot for the Winter season.
FATAL FINALE #PLL Death Theory:
Judging by the images from the promo stills and the official ABC Family promo, looks like My Mona will be the one to die :(
Also, Hanna in tears.
3 Nights Ago, According to Spencer
So I went back 3 night’s to try and figure out a connection to Spencer’s video footage of Melissa. This would take us to episode 5.08.
Aria was visiting Rhonda in Radley, who mentioned the woman with the beige purse that would sign Bethany out and take her on trips.
Hanna was being harassed by Zack.
Emily was being visited by Sydney, who slipped up about New York.
Alison was at the Marin house with Ashley because Hanna was upset about her being there.
Spencer was only heard on a phone call with Aria that night. The two were talking about how Aria got into trouble for giving Rhonda a sugary drink. The only males seen during this particular night were Caleb and Zack. Therefore, we rule both of them out as being the guy in the surveillance video because both were occupied.
At the end of this episode (5.08) we see ‘A’ looking at a riding hat. We noticed that this is the same hat Spencer took from the stables (Melissa’s) when she was hit in the eye. Meaning that the tape recording that Spencer hid in her red chair wasn’t what Melissa gave to the guy in the video footage like Spencer assumed. The Ali fake story recording was stolen 2 nights from the day Ali was to ID Cyrus.
Here’s the rundown of what could have been pulled off by 3 people:
- Hanna was inside her car eating when Zack ‘the Creep’ slipped in due to a note that was signed by Hanna but wasn’t written by Hanna. Although this was not signed by A, we can all assume that ‘A’ was behind this stunt. Zack told Caleb that Hanna slipped the note into his pocket, meaning someone put the note there the night before when Hanna went for a sandwich or possibly the same night he got into her car.
- Emily and Spencer were at the stables during this time and were locked in by a black hoodie.
- Alison was at the Marin house when another black hoodie broke into the home. Alison told the liars that this was Noel Kahn and I assumed it to be Cyrus, but I was wrong because why would Cyrus be wearing A-Team clothing? The person who broke into the Marin home wasn’t Cyrus at all, he was seen lurking outside the property due to Ali possibly calling him, meaning I don’t think a neighbor could identify him if he was covered in black head to toe with his face covered because ‘A’ wears a mask that covers his face now.
- Aria was at her home preparing the invitations for Ella’s dinner party.
Once Spencer and Emily made it home, Toby came by due to Spencer calling him and telling him about Melissa’s helmet that was at the stables. Spencer brought this helmet home (check the above pics) and placed it on her desk. Ali went back to her house to get some things to stay at the Marin’s and Emily and Spencer were there to find out what happened at Ashley’s home. When Spencer left her house, this was the perfect opportunity for ‘A’ to go up and get the recording.
Now, to figure out who could have been the male in Spencer’s video footage talking to Melissa. I already ruled out both Caleb and Zack because both guys were occupied at the particular time. It wasn’t Cyrus because looking at the close-up of the video the guy is a clean shaved male no hair from what I can tell. Which leaves me with three possible suspects:
- Ezra - who was supposed to be in New York at the the time, also he wears his baseball cap when he’s being a bada$$.
- Noel - who had a recording of his own, that he was shown with the same night of the break in at the Marin house but the recording wasn’t the same recording that was stolen from Spencer’s room.
- Jason - who recently moved out his home to a new place.
But I’m leaning more to the person that Melissa was talking to as being Noel Kahn. He had a device in a package and that’s probably what Melissa gave him, when he was seen in his car out on the street on the same night as the break in, meaning I rule him out as being the culprit who broke into the Marin home.
Therefore, I narrowed down the a likely ‘A’ suspect that went into the Hastings house to get the recording as Toby Cavanaugh.
Why? Because Spencer told him about the helmet that she got from the stables and he’s been in Spencer’s room several times, I’m pretty sure he stumbled across a few things of interest. Also, I still believe he is working with Mona and I think he was the car that pulled up when Jenna, Mona, and Sydney were at the park.
Also, I mentioned this was the acts of 3 people:
At the end of 5.10 we see ‘A’ folding 3 black hoodies, Mona and 2 girls at the park = 3 girls. Also, the story Mona told Spencer in 2.25, that number she claimed Ali gave her was Toby’s, we spotted this in the 3.24 finale.
So I believe that Mona locked Spencer and Emily in the stables, Jenna put the note in Zack’s pocket, Sydney broke into the Marin home, and Toby got the recording from the Hastings house.
Marlene King just posted this to her Instagram and I believe that is Alison in the Redcoat so my theory was right!! http://analyzinga.tumblr.com/post/58367772179/redcoats-plane-registered-at-the-same-place-duncan