Q:Did I miss something I'm confused. Didn't the police close Ali's case because they believe Ian did it?
That was the case at the beginning of Season 2. The 2A finale revealed Garrett giving Jenna Ali’s autopsy report which lead to Jenna giving the report to Toby in 2B (2.24) because she was upset with him. Once they turned in the report Garrett was arrested for the murder of Alison (2.24). They also, suspected that he killed Maya as well due to eye witness. This storyline continued into 3A (3.07) where Wilden was questioning Hanna about her blood matching the blood on the evidence that Spencer and Jason turned in (anklet). We did a theory on this one which relates to Mona if you’re interested in reading. But apparently, Alison’s case was never resolved and Wilden died still trying to figure out what happen.
Q:in the hitchcock film 'the man who knew too much' there is a place called ambrose chapel who they at first thought was a person, kind of a parallel with pll
Well, the writers tend to get inspiration from old Hitchcock films so your discovery is spot on.
Thanks for sharing this :)
Q:Do you know if Riley is appearing on the nect episodes?
Unfortunately, he will not be in the next 2 episodes :(
Q:In the Shadow Play episode the girls learn that Mona has been helping Ezra and in the last episode Emily confronts Mona about it and Mona admits to helping Ezra. Just something to add to your (fore)Shadow Play theory.
Thanks love!! Will update it after work today ;)
4.19 Shadow Play - Our foreshadowing theory was right!
We posted after Shadow Play aired that the episode was:
Our opinion about Shadow Play is that it wasn’t a dream at all. We believe the events that happened in the episode are a big jumble of events that have yet to happen. We looked deeper into the title and the writers of PLL are truly amazing, they tend to do a lot of foreshadowing within episodes and for this entire episode to be in black and white without any relation to actual events is not their style. They are creative geniuses and this episode is an entire foreshadowing of what’s to come.
So far our theory is right! Here’s some of the things that were mentioned in the 4.19 Shadow Play episode that we are seeing in current episodes:
1. You think she started up with Ezra and didn’t tell us …
In the 4.19 bathroom scene three little liars were discussing their friend’s relationship.”You think she started up with Ezra and didn’t tell us?” At the very end of the episode the same three little liars witness with their own eyes Aria and Ezra back together.
2. How was Syracuse …
In this week’s episode 4.22 ‘Cover for Me,’ Emily and Aria had a phone conversation. The conversation starts with “I’m still at Syracuse.” If we recall correctly Emily was the one to ask Aria “How was Syracuse” in the 4.19 episode and voila! Emily is the person that Aria is talking to on the phone. Also, Hanna asks her if she “had a good time with her dad” and of course Aria was at Syracuse with her dad.
3. Did you make it to the Eerie Canal Museum …
Now this connection is far-fetched so we please don’t consider this to be true, as we are theorizing with this one, it’s possible we are wrong about this. Spencer asks Aria in 4.19 “Did you make it to the Eerie Canal Museum?” Aria replies, ‘it was closed.’ In 4.20, Spencer tries to convince Emily and Hanna that ‘A’ changed the diary to make it seem as though it read “still thinking of Ambrose Pearson.” But as smart as Spencer is, she remembers that it used to Ambrose Pavilion which is in Norristown zoo.
This is just a theory but we were thinking that the mentioning of Eerie Canal Museum was a disguise for the Ambrose Pavilion name.
4. That’s not what you said before …
This scene from Shadow Play, we took it as Toby referring to the time that Spencer told him about Ali possibly being alive. We could be over thinking it, but this would make perfect sense that some of things from the episode were connected with actual events that already happened and that Spencer’s mind is retracing actual events with a mixture of future events.
"That not what you told me before." Spencer responds she was confused, we took this scene to the 4.01 scene when Spencer gives Toby a theory that Alison could be alive and that she brought them to the lodge because she wants to come home. But Toby is so convinced that she is dead, just like in the Shadow Play episode but there he mentions "Confused about her being dead, or confused about telling me the truth."
5. Smart enough to get away with murder …
On this part we won’t go into details because we’ve already posted a theory about this last night. Therefore, what Toby says to Spencer in 4.19 is that:
Spencer doesn’t get confused. Spencer’s the smart one. Maybe smart enough to get away with murder. Or smart enough to help her fake the whole thing.Or maybe she tricked you into helping. You ever consider that?
6. I wanna tell my friends, about us …
This scene actually happened before the Shadow Play scene and I must admit it was a very clever move on the writers part throwing this in right after it happened in 4.18 Hot for Teacher.
7. Looks familiar …
As we’ve said before the writers are very creative and we have no doubt in our minds that the Shadow Play episode was a foreshadowing of every episode we are seeing and or, have seen. I can’t wait for the finale, because if we are right about the foreshadowing then the dressing room scene with Ali is gonna be Amazing!!
We’ll add more to this soon.
Unbridled: Sneak Peek 3
Q:Can you rewatch season 1 ep 4 Can You Hear Me Now? And listen to when Ezra and Aria are arguing about in class. Do you think thats what happened that night??
OMG, the scene about the book right?? Will re-watch now :)
Q:As stated before, Marlene King said that A is in the pilot episode, and Wren is in that episode. I don´t remember seeing Mrs DiLaurentis in the first episode. D:
She was in the pilot episode but she was played by a different actress :)
Q:So, the thing with your Sara Harvey theory (which I love, BTW!)... wasn't it said she was seen AFTER Ali went missing? It couldn't be her in the grave/who Spencer hit because she was seen on/after Labor Day, remember?
Yes, that is what was said by one of her friends Avery, who is currently taking pills everyday since then. I think she thought she saw Sara but in reality it wasn’t :)
Q:Do you think Melissa killed the girl to protect Spencer? Also if Jessica is protecting someone who killed Ali, Jason maybe??
Ooo, now this is interesting! I wonder about the Hastings sisters and if Melissa would ever be that girl that Spencer once described back in Season 2. Mrs. D protecting Jason? That’s a good one as well, because he admitted to Aria that he felt like his “parents couldn’t look at him anymore because they knew they lost the wrong kid.” :)
Both of these are great!
Q:They played the same music on 4x22 when Ezra said goodbye and the 3x24 episode when they're broke up. Do you think there's hope for them in season 5? Can you make a gif set with these two episodes? Thanks :)
We would definitely make a gif set if we knew how, but unfortunately we don’t. I’m sorry :(
Q:If Mrs. D really does have a twin and the twin's daughter is Sara, maybe CeCe is also her daughter/Sara's sister. That could explain why CeCe hates the girls and is on the A team - because she thinks or knows Spencer killed her sister, and it also explains why her and Ali are so similar - because their cousins! Just a thought... :)
Q:what if mrs D is really A. think about it, A hasn't been sending text messages for a while and maybe hanna is right Mrs D doesn't even know how to text. lol it makes sense doesn't it ?? Haha
Lol, thanks for this :)